Make a Payment

from Matchett & Ward Insurance

To make a payment on your insurance policy, please send a check to your insurance company directly using the address displayed below. If there is not an address listed for your company, please contact us directly.

To see more information about a company, click on its name. Some of the companies we represent accept payments online. Use the link in the Online Payments column below to go to your company's online payment center.

Companies

CompanyAddressPhoneOnline Payments
Personal
Allstate 800-901-1732www.allstate.com
Arlington/Roe
Donegal Mutual 800-877-0600www.donegalgroup.com
Everett Cash Mutual
Foremost Insurance P.O. Box 0915
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0915
800-532-4221www.foremost.com
GMAC 877-468-3466www.secureinsforms.com
Harleysville Insurance Harleysville Insurance
Processing Center
P.O. Box 37712
Philadelphia, PA 19101-5012
866-665-4992paymentshmic.billmatrix.com
Indiana Farmers MutualOn-time payments
P.O. Box 856
Indianapolis, IN 46206-0856
Overnight Payments
10 W. 106th Street
P.O. Box 527
Indianapolis, IN 46290
888-809-3434www.indianafarmers.com
Kemper InsuranceWith payment stub
Kemper Auto & Home
P.O. Box 550750
Jacksonville, FL 32255
Without payment stub
Kemper Auto & Home
P.O. Box 70839
Charlotte, NC 28272-0839
888-252-2799www.ekemper.com
Liberty Mutual Liberty Mutual Group
ATTN: Remittance Processing
100 Liberty Way
Dover, NH 03821-7500
800-824-7317www.libertymutual.com
Mennonite Mutual
Progressive P.O. Box 4640
Carol Stream, IL 60197-9601
800-888-7764www.progressiveagent.com
Safeco P.O. Box 6476
Carol Stream, IL 60197-6476
800-332-3226customer.safeco.com
Selective Selective Insurance Company of America
Box 371468
Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468
888-974-7400customer1.selectiveinsurance.com
Spriska Specialty Risk of America
State Auto P.O. Box 182738
Columbus OH 43218-2738
800-444-9950www.stateauto.com
Travelers One Tower Square
Hartford, CT 06183-1001
877-878-2468mytravelers.com
Western Reserve Group P.O. BOX 740754
Cincinnati OH 45274-0754
866-558-2998paymentswrg.billmatrix.com
Commercial
Allstate 800-901-1732www.allstate.com
Am Trust North America
Arlington/Roe
Builders Insurancepay.bldrs.com
Donegal Mutual 800-877-0600www.donegalgroup.com
Everett Cash Mutual
FirstComp Insurance 888-500-3344www.firstcomp.com
Guard
Harleysville Insurance Harleysville Insurance
Processing Center
P.O. Box 37712
Philadelphia, PA 19101-5012
866-665-4992paymentshmic.billmatrix.com
Indiana Farmers MutualOn-time payments
P.O. Box 856
Indianapolis, IN 46206-0856
Overnight Payments
10 W. 106th Street
P.O. Box 527
Indianapolis, IN 46290
888-809-3434www.indianafarmers.com
Markel Insurancewww.markelinsurance.com
Mennonite Mutual
Philadelphia Insurance Philadelphia Insurance Companies
P.O. Box 70251
Philadelphia, PA 19176-0251
www.phly.com
Selective Selective Insurance Company of America
Box 371468
Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468
888-974-7400customer1.selectiveinsurance.com
State Auto P.O. Box 182738
Columbus OH 43218-2738
800-444-9950www.stateauto.com
W.R. Berkley Corporation
West Bend - NSI West Bend Mutual Insurance Company
Attention: Accounts Receivable
1900 South 18th Avenue
West Bend, WI 53095
800-573-1323paymentswestbend.billmatrix.com
Western Reserve Group P.O. BOX 740754
Cincinnati OH 45274-0754
866-558-2998paymentswrg.billmatrix.com
Life & Health
Allstate 800-901-1732www.allstate.com
Anthem 888-641-5224www.anthem.com
Cincinnati Life Insurance 800-783-4479
Lincoln Benefit Life 800-525-2799

For more, see our full list of insurance companies.

Contact Us

765-584-1261
Office hours:
8:30 AM - 5:00 PM M-F

Personal umbrella policy
Get additional loss protection

Your current insurance may not cover you fully in the event of a catastrophic loss. Learn more.

Winchester
107 W. Franklin Street
Winchester, IN 47394

765-584-1261

Office hours: 8:30AM - 5PM Mon - Fri